Event Recap | Funding Faculty Research - Meet and Greet with Foundation Funders for Early Career Scientists
About the Event
Dimitra Koutsantoni, Senior Director of University Corporate and Foundation Relations, led a conversation with Gerard Brandenstein, Managing Director of the Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation, Daniel Goroff, Vice President and Program Director of the Sloan Foundation, Anne Hultgren, Executive Director and CEO of the Arnold and Mabel Beckman Foundation, and Laura J. Kaufman, Columbia University Professor of Chemistry and Chair of the Department of Chemistry, on funding programs for early career faculty in STEM fields. The discussion covered the aims and goals of foundation fellowships, the selection process for candidates, differences between federal and foundation proposals, and the impact of early career awards on academic careers.
Key Takeaways
- Early Career Faculty Fellowships & Foundation Programs Overview
- Panelists detailed their respective foundation’s early career faculty fellowship and award programs (ie. Camille Dreyfus Teacher-Scholar Awards Program, the Beckman Young Investigator Fellowship, and the Sloan Research Fellowship), sharing specific insight into each award’s stated interests and requirements - see table below.
- These programs aim to support early career scientists in STEM fields, particularly focusing on innovative and interdisciplinary research proposals.
- Foundation Priorities and Selection Process
- Each foundation has specific priorities and selection criteria for its programs. Understanding these priorities is crucial for crafting competitive proposals.
- The selection process involves review by experts in the respective fields, emphasizing identifying candidates with promising and groundbreaking research ideas.
- Federal vs. Foundation Proposals
- Proposals submitted to foundations differ from those submitted to federal agencies. Foundations often have more flexibility in funding decisions and may be more open to unconventional projects. Understanding these differences and tailoring proposals accordingly is essential for your application’s success.
- Impact of Early Career Awards
- Receiving early career awards can significantly benefit faculty members' career trajectories. These awards not only enhance CVs but also signal research excellence to the academic community, leading to further recognition and funding opportunities.
- Additionally, foundation awards can support innovative research projects that may not receive funding from federal agencies.
- Successful Proposals
- Panelists emphasized the importance of aligning research proposals with the foundation’s core mission.
- They encouraged early career scientists not to underestimate the value of their ideas and to seek advice when considering applying for funding opportunities.
- They also highlighted the supportive and flexible nature of foundation funding, which allows recipients to pursue their research goals more effectively.
Key Similarities and Differences
- Program:
- Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation
- Camille Dreyfus Teacher-Scholar Awards Program
- Beckman Foundation
- Beckman Young Investigator
- Sloan Foundation
- Sloan Research Fellowship
- Disciplines Funded:
- Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation
- Chemical sciences (chemistry, biochemistry, materials chemistry, and chemical engineering)
- Beckman Foundation
- Chemical and life sciences
- Sloan Foundation
- Chemistry, computer science, Earth system science, economics, mathematics, neuroscience, physics, or a related field
- Applicant Eligibility:
- Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation
- Applicants must be within the first six years of their independent academic careers at the time of submission of the nomination
- Foundation is happy to discuss any question about eligibility
- Beckman Foundation
- Applicants must be within the first four years of a tenure-track position, or an equivalent independent research appointment.
- Applicants must have no more than 10 years post-terminal degree; and no more than 5 years experience in a non-tenure track (not including postdoc position) or industry position.
- Sloan Foundation
- Applicants must be tenure-track, though untenured, as of September 15 of the nomination year
- Institutional Eligibility:
- Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation
- Institutions may submit only one Camille Dreyfus Teacher-Scholar Award nomination annually
- Required: a letter of nomination from an institutional representative highlighting the nominee’s research and teaching accomplishments
- Beckman Foundation
- Institutions are not limited in the number of applicants who apply at the Letter of Intent stage.
- Required: Two Endorsements by
- (1) Chief Academic Officer (President, Chancellor, Provost) or similarly authorized signatory, and (2) Dean of the College/School/Division for the participating Academic Unit or similarly authorized signatory
- Sloan Foundation
- More than one candidate from a department may be nominated per fellowship field, but no more than three.
- Required: letter of nomination from a department head or other senior researcher
- Ideal Proposal and Candidate:
- Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation
- The program is looking for:
- leadership in original scholarly research of outstanding quality
- innovation in and dedication to education.
- Beckman Foundation
- The program is looking for:
- interdisciplinary proposals
- very risky projects that probably would not be funded through some of the more traditional government funding mechanisms
- people to step into a different direction
- innovative science: projects that are not the next logical step in moving forward a research program that's already ongoing in the lab
- Sloan Foundation
- The program supports people not projects
- Sloan asks for very little about applicants’ current research projects
- The emphasis is more on the nomination, the recommendation letters and the kind of work that an applicant has done already
- Review Process:
- Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation
- Applications are assessed by a review panel of distinguished faculty in the chemical sciences
- Foundation staff offer administrative guidance, they do not enter a vote in the process
- Foundation Trustees are interested in spreading around the number of institutions that win these prizes
- Beckman Foundation
- Blind review process: information pertaining to applicants’ name, gender, ethnicity, citizenship status, and institutional information is hidden from all reviewers
- The Foundation wants to diversify the institutions they are funding and prevent implicit bias towards particular institutions
- Reviewers are recruited across a very wide range of disciplines, and are not necessarily matched to what applicants are potentially planning to submit
- Sloan Foundation
- Nominations are reviewed and candidates selected by an independent selection committee of distinguished scientists in each eligible field.
- Each field has its own committee
Speakers
Dimitra Koutsantoni
Dimitra Koutsantoni is Senior Director of University Corporate and Foundation Relations at Columbia University. Dimitra works with Columbia University academic and administrative leaders and faculty to develop and deepen partnerships with foundations and corporations in support of university strategic initiatives, programs, and faculty research. Prior to that, she served as the Director of Research Administration at Columbia University Irving Medical Center where she led the administration and management of the Department of Pediatrics’ portfolio of grants and clinical trials. Dimitra has also held research administration and foundation relations positions in Columbia’s Sponsored Projects Administration and Business School. Before coming to Columbia in 2010, Dimitra headed up research development and knowledge transfer at Bayes Business School (formerly Cass), City University London. A social scientist by training, Dimitra holds a PhD in Sociolinguistics and has published a research monograph, peer reviewed journal articles, and higher education policy papers.
Gerard Brandenstein
With almost 35 years of dedicated service to the Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation, Gerard Brandenstein was named Managing Director in January 2024. He is also a member of Touro University’s Institutional Review Board. He has continued his postgraduate education with studies at Harvard Business School and Cornell Law School.
Daniel Goroff
Daniel Goroff serves as Vice President and Program Director at the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. He is a particularly passionate patron of rigorous and policy-relevant research in the social sciences, while also running the Sloan Research Fellowship Program that funds promising junior faculty in a variety of disciplines. Daniel Goroff is Professor Emeritus of Mathematics and Economics at Harvey Mudd College in Claremont, where he also served as Dean of the Faculty and Vice President for Academic Affairs.
Anne Hultgren
Anne Hultgren joined the Arnold and Mabel Beckman Foundation in 2015 as Executive Director and CEO. Previously, she served at the Department of Homeland Security within the Science and Technology Directorate, specializing in chemical and biological defense technologies.. She received her PhD in Physics and Astronomy from Johns Hopkins University, and BA in Physics and Mathematics from Franklin and Marshall College.
Laura J. Kaufman
Laura J. Kaufman is Professor of Chemistry and Chair of the Department of Chemistry, A&S at Columbia University. Her research considers the dynamics of crowded systems, including biopolymer gels, supercooled liquids and conjugated polymers. She has received numerous prestigious awards, including the Beckman Young Investigator Award and the Camille Dreyfus Teacher Scholar Award.