Tenure Review Guidelines

Columbia employs a standing committee system to conduct a final University-wide evaluation whenever a school or department, including Barnard College but excepting the Faculty of Law and Teachers College, recommends a candidate for tenure. This evaluation is the culmination of a process of review involving multiple considerations of the nomination within the department and school. The purpose of the final review is to confirm that the earlier reviews were rigorous and substantive and that all candidates meet the same high standards, regardless of the school or department originating the nomination. By examining both the process by which candidates are nominated and their qualifications, the standing committee seeks to ensure a University-wide consistency in the evaluation of nominations to tenure and thereby to promote the appointment of faculty of exceptional quality and distinction throughout the institution.

The standing committee–the Tenure Review Advisory Committee (TRAC)–serves in an advisory capacity to the provost who determines whether the candidate should be recommended to the president and trustees for tenure. The University’s standing committee system of tenure review is administered on behalf of the provost by the vice provost for faculty affairs.

TRAC members

Michael Ting (Chair)
Professor of International and Public Affairs and Political Science

Suzanne Bakken
Alumni Professor of the School of Nursing and Professor of Biomedical Informatics

Keren Bergman
Charles Batchelor Professor of Electrical Engineering; Scientific Director, Center for Integrated Science and Engineering

Gil Eyal
Professor of Sociology

Pierre Force
Professor of French and of History

Ali Gharavi 
Jay Meltzer, M.D. Professor of Nephrology and Hypertension (in Medicine)

Ann McDermott
Esther Breslow Professor of Biological Chemistry and Professor of Biological Sciences and Chemical Engineering

Cathy Lee Mendelsohn
Michael and Stella Chernow Professor of Urological Sciences (in Urology) and Pathology and Cell Biology and Genetics and Development (in the Institute of Human Nutrition)

Molly Przeworski
Professor of Biological Sciences and Systems Biology

John Santelli
Professor of Population and Family Health and Pediatrics

Joanna Stalnaker
Professor of French and Romance Philology; Paul Brooke Chair for Literature and Humanities

Olivier Toubia
Glaubinger Professor of Business

David Weiman
Professor of Economics, Barnard College

Tenure Review Advisory Committee Statistics

The Principles and Customs Governing University-wide Tenure Reviews policy governs TRAC’s review of all tenure nominations with the exception of those originating in Barnard College (read the Barnard College Tenure Guidelines). The procedures followed in evaluating candidates from Barnard College differ in some respects, as provided for in the inter-institutional agreement between the College and the University. Therefore, the process by which Barnard nominations are reviewed is described in a separate document